The Fear of NFTs

https://unitlondon.com/whats-on/84-group-exhibition-nftism-no-fear-in-trying/

It’s a human defence mechanism to reject the unfamiliar without giving it a chance; change is hard to stomach, something that unsettles the status quo. Human nature pushes back at first blush rather than learn about and accept something new for what it is—a potential advance and step forward. NFTs are just such a transformative phenomenon, a potential revolution in the history of art and its dissemination into the collective stream of consciousness, and commerce! This show will attempt to do what no one has done before! FOCUS ON THE ART, art from a wide, diverse universe of talent from all walks of life.

Kenny Schachter, curator of NFTismNFear in Trying

Reflective Writing: The “Art” in Crypto Art

I have to confess that I was so nervous every time when I was asked what NFT is or how to join NFT for the past few months since I have started this project.

Doubtlessly, this is a big question, and as everybody knows, what is behind the blockchain is a complex algorithm that 99% person would never figure out. However, I felt so pressured when I have to provide a perfect and integral answer for the question because I don’t want to let them down. 

But why should everybody know everything about NFT? 

I still don’t know how these stock works, but I buy my breakfast smoothly every day and could appreciate the artworks well in galleries. The technology thing would never be the star in the art world unless some artists wanna create some pieces about that. Art is always concerned with feeling, aesthetics is always about what we sense. It is regret that we turned away from Crypto Art just because we don’t know blockchain, besides the squares is never the thing. 

For now, I’d like to leave the techs away, focus on the art itself. What Crypto Art could be different from traditional Art? What we could bring to Crypto Art in this era? As an art lover, what can I bring to my stakeholders?

However, the stakeholders won’t change under this situation, because my role is more like an art dealer, I need to associate with artists and buyers and relevant art workers at the same time.

Fortunately, I feel more confident about what I am doing.

Stakeholder: Yusi Liu

Yusi Liu, <Stray Cat>, 2021

I met Yusi in 2015 when we began our bachelor degree. Now she is studying painting at Shanghai Normal University. As following is a brief of our conversation.

Crypto Art

Yusi had heart about NFTs and Crypto Art, but only a bit. She thinks she would be in the top per cent of the Chinses, cause rare students would talk about it, and even the tutors didn’t know about it. Mostly they got news from their friends who are studying abroad.

So I introduced the concept and the big news in the Crypto world to her.

Some problems we found that could not solve immediately for Chinese artists :

  • Language
  • Having no idea where and how to upload
  • Expensive gas fee

For collectors:

  • Why need to buy it?
  • The Wechat program Pingmujian (started from 2017) is a similar model logic as the platform for crypto Art, but seldom people buy in
  • Still a big question left in traditional art world, especially Chinese, only the minorities spend money on it
Where would Chinese spend money most
  • Designer toy like Takashi Murakami, Kaws
  • Digital prints for commercial purpose
Reflection

From Yusi’s perspective, promoting the digital exhibition could be a way that promotes crypto artwork. In China, most people do not know about Crypto art yet, which means there’s also a huge space to do something.

During the conversation, we also talked about our views towards Chinese and “western” painting. We both agree that they are so different that will appeal to a different audience. Though personally, I like the Chinese style more, because of the typical Chinese aesthetics, while Yusi would prefer the “western”, due to the creative expression. This is a big topic and we discussed it a lot but this is a crypto blog so I won’t talk more. Anyway, it’s good to know the different attitudes.

For the next step of my intervention, I shall focus on the promotion of digital art. Also, let more Chinese artists know more about Crypto art.

China Crypto Art Map

Marketplace

  • Golden Legend
  • ibox.com
  • CRYPTOART.AI
  • myNFT
  • TopBidder
  • iNFT
  • Binance NFT
  • nft arts
  • MetaOpus
  • ArtGee
  • NFTBOX

DAO

decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) is an entity with no central leadership. Decisions get made from the bottom-up, governed by a community organized around a specific set of rules enforced on a blockchain. DAOs are internet-native organizations collectively owned and managed by their members.

  • MAO DAO
  • G Art Fund
  • Vulcan Dao
  • MAA DAO
  • DAOSquare
  • National Architects
  • Yeah Dao

Gallery

  • Shanghai Gallery
  • CHIJIN Museum
  • ArtGee
  • WaveC
  • Ting Song Museum

Artist

  • Cai Guo-Qiang
  • Wu Di
  • Zhang Zhi-Wei
  • Wu Jian-An
  • Liu Xin
  • Roxie Ren
  • Loxel
  • Sun Yi-Dian
  • Liu Gang
  • Huang He-Shan
  • Yu Wang
  • Rui Huang
  • Lulu
  • BonnyBB
  • Jeffreysxy
  • DABEIYUZHOU
  • Sleepy
  • Richthefan
  • Yuan Jin-Hua
  • Daidi319
  • Liu Jia-Ying

Cruator

  • Cao Yin
  • Will Lang
  • Sun Bo-Han
  • Qin Jian-Xin
  • Ting Song
  • Guo Cheng
  • Yang Ga

Infrastructure

  • TOUCHAIN
  • AlchemyNFT
  • xNFT

Stakeholder: Yuxin Cheng

X’Diptera, Dabeiyuzhou, 2020

Yuxin is my CSM classmate, she currently is working at BCA as a curator.

BCA is a full-category blockchain art NFT platform that integrates blockchain art creation, investment collection and education output. It is centred on MetaOpus and is committed to creating a person Encrypted art ecosystem where everyone can participate.

As following is the summary of our conversation:

BCA
  • 30-40 staff members
  • Mainly young artist (millerals, and gen Z)
  • Top artists: Dabeiyuzhou, Zhiwei Zhang (acution)
  • Aiming to develop young artists
Bohan Sun
  • Founder of BCA
  • The current development of Crypto art is inseparable from the construction of infrastructure
  • To cultivate a group of collectors
  • The current crypto art auction payment process has a high threshold
  • There is still a gap between the current national aesthetic perception level and foreign markets, we need to find ways to participate in this industry with more Chinese or local characteristics
MetaOpus
  • 80k+user, 500+ signed artitsts
  • Chinese > users from other countries
Reflection

I used to believe that some people criticize that digital art is not “real” art, but who decides what is “real” art? After the conversation with Yuxi, also the study of Bohan, I will first propose that physical art is not real art, real art only exists in digital In the world. In fact, art is art, and it can appear in any form. The reason why art is amazing is that it does not need to be widely admired, it is only created for creation.

BCA is a pioneer organisation in China, it is so lucky for me that being Yuxin’s classmate. She told me a lot of information about the BCA that I couldn’t share here, but it is so important for me to understand more about the Chinese crypto industry.

I. Chinese Platform Study

A. Primary Market

1. BCA

MetaOpus
  • Chinese friendly, Chinese artist > English
  • 500+ Artists, 80k users. Start from 5.2021
  • Acution: 大悲宇宙,张知微
  • Artists development, like MCN media, cooporate with emerging artist
  • Model: 2/8, no gas fee
MetaOpus homepage
Virtual Niche Have you ever seen memes in the mirror?
  • The world’s first Cryptoart exhibition
  • Featured works include Robert Alice’s “Portraits of a mind”, the first ever NFT artwork sold by Christie’s auction house. In addition, 20 works by artist, Beeple will make their first ever debut appearance in China.
  • Aim to showcase artists using blockchain technology as a medium for creating dialogue and connection between the institutional art world and the crypto community.
Virtual Niche exhibition post
BCA Gallery
  • Online (wechat program) and in-person exhibition (pop-up)
BCA Gallery wechat program screenshot

2. NFTcn

Service
  • Mint
  • promotion
  • Trading
    • Put on SuperRare, Rarible … 
    • Characteristic service 
      • All Chinese
      • No background knowledge needed
      • No digital wallet needed
Process of submitting works
  • Application
  • Waiting for customer service contacting
  • Upload works
  • Waiting for the buyer or send it as a gift to collector
  • Sold
    • 10% commission fee
    • RMB & Cryptocurrency accepted 
Chinese only problems solving
  • Not familiar with blockchain, digital wallets, etc.
  • No need to understand blockchain, digital wallets, etc.
  • Not familiar with how to generate NFT works on overseas NFT platforms
  • Simultaneous sale of overseas NFT platforms
  • Lack of exposure and no trading volume after the works are on the chain
  • Intelligent matching of potential collectors after the work is on the chain
  •  No IP targeting
  • Collective promotion makes it easier to be discovered by overseas collectors
  • “Expensive” gas fee (around $250)
  • No casting gas fee (only ¥300 manual review fee is required for the first review. If the review fails, a full refund will be issued.)

3. Pinmujian

  • Start from March 2021, focused on digital art, but similar model as Cryoto art trading.

II. English Platform Study

A. Primary Market

1. SuperRare

  • Require submission (couple weeks)
    • Portfolio required
  • Aim to be the curated single edition rare artwork place
    • To be like the instagram meets Christie’s
  • Great user interface and diligently updating
  • Repost very often on social with their artists having news or releases
  • One of the premier places
superrare.com homepage
SuperRare Editorial page

2. MakersPlace

  • Curated
    • Require submission
    • Curation seems to be more broader than other platforms
    • Variety of artistic styles
  • To empower digital creators with creating a marketplace to sell their creations
  • Having issues with artist plagiarism
  • Credit card available
makersplace.com homepage

3. Rarible

  • Community owned  platform
    • Open to everyone, a trash and treasure of crypto art space – a flea market
      • All sorts of trash
      • Definitely treasures if you know what you’re looking for
    • Wide audience
      • Difficulty to get discovered if not verified
      • even got verified ticked couldn’t get discovered organically when posting
    • Possibly looking for bargains
      • Not the high end of crypto art market
      • But may be worth trying out to get feet wet selling
  • Copyright infringement and plagiarism
rarible.com homepage

4. Nifty Gateway

  • Invitation only
    • Scheduled artist drop events
  • To make NFT art accessible to everyone
    • Platform teaming with top artists to make quality limited edition drops with hype releases
      • Name an upcoming artist and the date then spread the hype
      • Only available for a short time
      • Often sell out within minutes or seconds
      • Then they have a secondary marketplace 
  • Curator’s collection 
    • Artists could recommended by creators 
niftygateway.com homepage

5. OpenSea

  • Catch-all mothership for digital collectibles like eBay
opensea.io homepage

6. Async

  • With programmable digital art that can evolve or change over time
async.art homepage

7. Foundation

foundation.app homepage

8. hic et nunc

hicetnunc.xyz homepage

Reflective Writing: General Impression

So far I interviewed 31 people, including my friends, my teachers, and strangers I’ve never met. Some are short conversations, some are longer than we exchanged opinions. 74% of them had no idea about this topic, and most of them stand that “all I’ve seen is negative stuff about how it affects the environment”, or strongly believe that current crypto art is not about art, it’s all about cryptocurrency, this will fade away soon.

I agree with what they said, like NFT is hurting the environment, the artwork is not “art” enough. Also the instability, we don’t know if the NFT would disappear tomorrow like the Chinese government banned Bitcoin today, or it just would be abandoned by the public’s choice. But nothing you will know about the future. Everything fades away, but NFT is happening, Crypto Art is booming, and I think this is interesting. 

The NFT workers are resolving the environmental issues, we could invite more great artists into the world. We could build something different.